FacebookTwitterLinkedInTelegramCopy LinkEmail
Blockchain

Ethereum Could Raise the Cost of Onboarding New Users

Ethereum Could Raise the Cost of Onboarding New Users

Ethereum’s proposed state repricing would make a user’s first interaction with an app cost more than their hundredth—and in most onboarding paths, someone other than the user pays.

Key Takeaways

  • New accounts and storage slots cost 4.9-7.3× more
  • Funding a fresh address: 204,600 gas proposed
  • An old wallet still pays for new tokens
  • Sponsored smart wallets move the bill to apps

EIP-8037, scheduled for the Glamsterdam hardfork, raises the cost of adding accounts, code and storage to Ethereum’s state and meters that cost on a separate gas dimension. For an application bringing in customers, the question that follows is which of those records its first interaction creates, and whether the customer or the business pays for them.

There are three common ways a person arrives at an Ethereum app: an exchange or faucet funds a brand-new address, an existing wallet receives a token it has never held, or the app deploys a smart wallet on the user’s behalf. Each creates a different amount of state, and each sends the bill to a different party.

Glamsterdam charges for new state, not new users

Under EIP-8037, every operation that permanently enlarges Ethereum’s state, a new account, a new storage slot, a byte of deployed contract code, is priced in “state bytes” at a fixed rate of 1,530 gas per byte. A new account is counted as 120 bytes, a new storage slot as 64. Everything else a transaction does is charged as execution gas, which keeps its familiar meter.

The purpose is to let the block gas limit rise without the state database every node must store rising with it. The Hoodi testnet activation that was cancelled in October had been paired with a planned increase to a 200 million gas limit, from roughly 60 million today. Separating state gas means that extra capacity can go to computation while state growth stays bounded.

Two of the resulting charges matter most for onboarding:

Charge Today Proposed
New account 25,000 183,600 (×7.3)
New storage slot 20,000 97,920 (×4.9)
Deployed code, per byte ~200 1,530 (×7.7)

A companion proposal, EIP-8038, reprices reads and writes to state that already exists. That matters for the baseline: “repeat use” is not frozen at today’s cost either, so any comparison has to run both proposals under the same assumptions rather than treating existing-account activity as unchanged.

Path one: funding a fresh address

Generating a wallet costs nothing on-chain. As Ethereum’s account documentation explains, the address is derived from the public key, so a user can hold a valid address that the network has never heard of. The account record only comes into existence when something touches that address, typically the first ETH deposit.

EIP-2780 splits the old flat 21,000-gas transfer into its parts: a 12,000 base cost, 6,000 for carrying value and 3,000 for touching the recipient. A transfer to an account that already exists stays at that 21,000 of execution gas. A transfer that brings a new account into existence adds the 183,600 state-gas charge from the table above, for 204,600 in total.

The sender pays. An exchange processing a withdrawal to a freshly generated address, a faucet, or an onboarding service that seeds users with gas money absorbs that charge before the recipient has opened a single app. For a service that funds thousands of first-time addresses, the state component is now the bulk of the transaction, not a rounding error on top of it.

Path two: a token the wallet has never held

The second path is subtler, because the user is not new at all. Someone who has held ETH for years receives a stablecoin for the first time. Their account exists, but their balance in that token does not.

In OpenZeppelin’s standard ERC-20 implementation, balances live in a mapping inside the token contract. The recipient’s entry sits at zero until the first transfer writes a positive number into it, and under the proposed rules, that zero-to-positive write is a new storage slot at 97,920 state gas, on top of the execution gas the transfer uses anyway. Topping up an existing positive balance reuses the slot and pays no state gas.

Two consequences follow. First, “new user” is the wrong unit: the chargeable event is a new record, and a long-standing wallet creates one every time it enters an application it has not used before. Second, the record belongs to the token contract, not to the user’s account, so receiving a token never creates an account at the recipient’s address, only a slot in someone else’s storage.

The charge is not necessarily paid once per wallet lifetime, either. A balance that is spent down to zero and later refilled produces another zero-to-positive write. Whoever sends the tokens, an exchange, a payroll contract, an airdrop, pays for it.

Path three: a sponsored smart wallet

Smart-wallet onboarding moves all of the above off the user and onto the application. The app deploys a contract account for the customer, writes its initial settings into storage and executes the first action, often in one bundle.

ERC-4337 supports this through factories, which deploy the account, and paymasters, which cover the user’s gas from funds deposited with the EntryPoint contract. The customer never needs to acquire ETH. The trade is that onboarding becomes a line item in the provider’s budget, and under EIP-8037 that line item is dominated by state: 183,600 for the new account, 1,530 per byte of code written to it and 97,920 for every storage slot the initialisation fills.

How heavy that is depends on the wallet design. A minimal proxy that delegates to shared logic writes only a few dozen bytes of code; a full implementation deployed per user writes kilobytes. A consumer app that deploys a wallet for every sign-up has a very different exposure from a DeFi protocol whose users mostly arrive with existing accounts. None of the major paymaster providers has published revised sponsorship pricing, so for now the exposure is something each provider has to model from the spec.

The four scenarios side by side

Putting the three onboarding paths next to ordinary repeat use shows where the state charge lands and who carries it. All figures are gas under the proposed rules; the wallet-deployment row is an illustration built from the spec’s constants, not a measurement of any particular product.

Fresh address receives ETH

204,600

21,000 execution + 183,600 state

Pays: the sender (exchange, faucet, onboarding service)

Existing wallet, first token

+97,920

state gas on top of the transfer’s execution gas

Pays: whoever sends the tokens

Smart wallet deployed for user

≈350,000+

183,600 account + 68,850 for a 45-byte proxy + 97,920 per initial slot, plus execution

Pays: the app, via its paymaster

Repeat use, existing records

0 state gas

execution gas only, repriced separately by EIP-8038

Pays: the user

The pattern is the same in every row: the party that triggers the first record pays for it, and that party is usually not the person being onboarded. The one case where the user does pay, repeat use, is the case where no state is created at all.

In money terms, the fee still multiplies gas by the gas price and converts at ETH’s market price, neither of which the proposal sets. As an illustration only: at a 1 gwei gas price and an assumed $3,000 ETH, funding a fresh address would cost about $0.61 under the proposed rules against roughly $0.14 for the same transfer today. At 20 gwei those figures become about $12 and $2.80. Whether the capacity increase eases congestion enough to pull gas prices down is a question of demand that the specification cannot answer.

Where the proposal stands

As of November 16 the changes remain proposals. The Ethereum Foundation’s November 6 notice, written by researcher Marius van der Wijden and updated November 9, said compatibility findings had delayed the hardfork process and that Hoodi would not fork until the issues were resolved. Developers are working through eight invariants that existing contracts rely on and that EIP-8037 and EIP-8038 would break; the November 9 update reported four submissions identifying deployed contracts that could be affected.

Possible specification revisions were being prepared for discussion on November 19. That is a discussion date, not an activation date, and the constants above could move with it. Coindoo’s earlier piece on how the proposed gas rules affect existing contracts covers the compatibility side.

For anyone running an onboarding budget, the useful work now is to rerun the four scenarios above with their own wallet bytecode, their own initialisation and the same gas-price assumptions, and to watch the November 19 outcome for changes to the per-byte rate. The headline charges may be revised, but the structure, new state is what costs, and the sponsor pays, is the part of Glamsterdam that onboarding economics will have to absorb.

Author
Alex Stephanov is Editor-in-Chief of Coindoo

Reporter at Coindoo

Alex is Editor-in-Chief of Coindoo and co-founder of Millennial Media Group, with nearly a decade of experience covering financial markets - crypto first, then everything else. It started in 2016 with Bitcoin. Like most people at the time, he didn't fully understand it - so he kept digging. Blockchain, tokenomics, the projects, the cycles. That curiosity never stopped, and eventually pulled him into traditional markets too: equities, commodities, macro. Not because he left crypto behind, but because you can't properly understand one without the other. What drives him is straightforward: he wants to know why something is happening, not just that it's happening. Most market coverage stops at the headline - price up, price down, here's a chart. Alex finds that kind of reporting actively unhelpful. If you walk away from an article without understanding the mechanism behind the move, what did you actually learn? He holds a degree in Tourism from New Bulgarian University - not the most obvious path into financial markets, but markets have a way of pulling in people who are simply too curious to stay out. He has authored over 200 in-depth analyses and more than 10,000 articles across crypto and traditional finance. He still thinks every day in markets teaches him something new. That's probably why he hasn't stopped.

Learn more about crypto and blockchain technology.

Glossary